Why Saving and Investing Do Not Have to Be an Either-Or Decision
Saving and investing are often presented as alternatives: either keep your money in savings or invest it. When you have several financial goals, that can be the wrong way to frame the decision.
Different parts of your money may need to do different jobs. Money intended for something relatively soon may need greater certainty about the amount available, while money connected to a much more distant goal may have more time to experience the rises and falls that come with investing.
Saving can provide greater certainty about the cash value available, although inflation can reduce what that money can buy over time and interest rates can change. Investing introduces greater uncertainty because investment values can fall as well as rise, but it also provides the possibility of longer-term growth.
This means one financial plan can contain both savings and investments without the two competing against each other. The useful question is not simply should I save or invest? It is what does each part of my money need to achieve?
Saving vs Investing: What’s the Difference? explains the fundamental differences between the two. When several goals exist at once, those differences can then be considered separately for each goal.
Start by Separating Your Financial Goals
Before deciding how much money belongs in savings and how much might be invested, identify the goals the money is intended to support.
For example, someone might want to replace a car in two years, build money towards another goal in six years and have a third financial objective that is more than 15 years away. Treating all three as one pot of money hides an important difference between them.
Each goal has its own amount, timeframe and level of flexibility. The consequences of having less money than expected can also be different. Delaying one goal might be relatively straightforward, while another may need to happen at a particular time.
This is why starting with a percentage such as 50% saving and 50% investing can put the decision in the wrong order. The percentage tells you how the money has been divided, but not whether that division reflects what the money needs to do.
Start with the goals themselves. Once those are clear, you can consider the role saving and investing might play in each one.
Give Each Goal Its Own Timeframe
Timeframe is one of the most important differences between financial goals. A goal two years away and a goal 15 years away should not automatically be treated as though the money has the same amount of time available.
Consider three goals belonging to the same person. The first is expected in two years, the second in seven years and the third in 15 years. The person’s age, income and overall financial position are identical in each case, but the money has three different time horizons.
For the two-year goal, there is relatively little time between today and the point at which the money may be needed. If investments fell significantly during that period, there might be little opportunity to wait before making the planned withdrawal.
The seven-year goal has more time, but seven years does not guarantee a positive investment outcome. The 15-year goal has a substantially longer period in which investment values can change, although the eventual outcome still cannot be known in advance.
The point is not to create a rule saying that a particular number of years automatically means saving or investing. It is to recognise that the timeframe belongs to the goal rather than to your finances as a whole.
What Does Investment Time Horizon Mean? explains why the period before money is needed can change the significance of investment uncertainty.
How Certain Is the Date When You Will Need the Money?
Timeframe alone does not tell you everything. Two goals that are both five years away can create very different decisions if one has a fixed deadline and the other is flexible.
Suppose one amount of money will definitely be required in five years. If investments are worth less at that point, waiting another few years may not be an option.
Now consider a different goal that you would like to achieve in around five years but could postpone if necessary. A fall in investment value at the intended date could still be disappointing, but the flexibility to wait changes the practical consequences.
The amount of flexibility therefore matters alongside the number of years. Asking when would I like to use the money? and when must I use the money? can sometimes produce different answers.
Should You Invest Money You Might Need in Five Years? explores this distinction in more detail, including why uncertainty about when money will be needed can be as important as the five-year period itself.
What Would Happen If the Money Were Worth Less When You Needed It?
Investment risk can feel abstract until it is connected to the financial goal. One way to make it more practical is to consider what would happen if the amount available were lower than expected when the goal arrived.
Suppose a goal requires £20,000 but investments are worth £16,000 when the money is needed. Could the goal be postponed? Could its cost be reduced? Is there another source of money, or would the goal no longer be possible as planned?
The answers do not determine whether you should save or invest, but they reveal how significant a fall in value could be.
Saving and Investing Solve Different Problems
The balance depends on what a particular financial goal needs from the money rather than on one approach being universally better.
Greater certainty about the cash amount
Savings can make the amount available easier to anticipate, although interest rates can change and inflation can reduce what the money can buy over time.
Greater uncertainty with potential for growth
Investments can provide the possibility of longer-term growth, but their value can fall and the amount available on a particular future date cannot be known in advance.
A goal with little flexibility may place greater importance on certainty, while a goal with a longer or more flexible timeframe may be able to accommodate more uncertainty. That does not create a universal rule for where the money should be held.
This is why the appropriate balance can differ from one goal to another. The question is not whether investment risk is good or bad in isolation, but what that uncertainty would mean for the particular money if the outcome were unfavourable.
What Is Investment Risk? looks more closely at the different ways an investment outcome can differ from what you expected.
Can One Financial Goal Use Both Saving and Investing?
A financial goal does not necessarily have to be entirely funded through savings or entirely through investments. Different parts of the same goal can sometimes have different jobs.
Suppose a goal has a target of £40,000. Part of that amount may represent money that will definitely be required, while another part might support additional spending that could be reduced or postponed. The consequences of uncertainty are different for those two parts even though they belong to the same overall goal.
Time can create another distinction. A goal may initially be far enough away for some money to have a long investment timeframe, but that timeframe does not remain constant. If the date stays fixed, a goal that is 12 years away today will eventually be five years away and later just one year away.
That means the role of saving and investing within a goal does not have to remain unchanged throughout its life. As the money gets closer to being used, the consequences of investment movements can become more immediate.
This does not mean that money must automatically be moved from investments into savings according to a fixed timetable. It means that the balance can be reviewed as the purpose, remaining timeframe and flexibility of the goal change.
How Do You Divide New Money Between Different Goals?
Once several goals have been identified, the next question may be how to divide the money available each month between them.
Suppose £500 a month is genuinely available after other financial commitments. There is no universal rule saying how much of that £500 should be saved and how much should be invested. The answer depends on what the separate goals require.
Start by looking at each goal individually. How much might be needed? How much has already accumulated? How long remains? How firm is the deadline? How much could realistically be contributed?
For a savings goal, the Savings Time Calculator can help explore how long it could take to reach a target based on the starting balance, regular contributions and assumed savings rate.
For a longer-term investment goal, the Investment Growth Calculator can show how a starting amount, regular contributions, timeframe and assumed investment return interact. The return entered is an illustration rather than a forecast of what investments will actually achieve.
Using the calculators for separate goals can reveal competing demands on the same £500. One goal might require a larger contribution to meet a relatively firm deadline, while another has more time available. Alternatively, the combined contribution requirements might exceed the amount currently available.
That is useful information. It shows that the problem is not simply how to divide £500 between saving and investing; it may also involve reconsidering the target, timeframe or priority of individual goals.
What If Several Goals Compete for the Same Money?
Financial goals rarely exist independently of one another. Increasing the amount directed towards one goal can reduce what is available for another, particularly when both rely on the same monthly income.
This makes prioritisation different from choosing between savings and investments. A nearer goal is not automatically more important than a distant one, and a longer-term investment goal is not automatically more important because it has more time to grow.
Instead, consider what happens if each goal receives less than originally planned. A goal with a fixed date may have limited flexibility. Another may be capable of moving by several years. A third might have a target amount that can be adjusted.
The purpose of this exercise is not to rank every goal permanently. It is to understand the trade-offs created when several goals depend on the same limited pool of money.
Where several goals are specifically being funded through investments, How to Invest When You Have More Than One Financial Goal looks more closely at managing their different targets, timeframes and contribution requirements.
What Happens as One of Your Goals Gets Closer?
The balance between saving and investing should not necessarily be treated as a decision made once and then forgotten. Time passes, and the relationship between the money and its goal changes with it.
A goal ten years away today becomes five years away after five years if its intended date remains unchanged. A market fall that occurs early in that period may have very different practical consequences from one occurring shortly before the money is required.
Other things can change as well. The amount already accumulated may be higher or lower than expected. The target may change. The date may become firmer or more flexible, while the amount you can contribute could increase or decrease.
This is why reviewing the goal itself can be more useful than simply reviewing whether investments have performed well. The question is whether the current balance still fits what the money now needs to do.
What Should Happen to Your Investments as Your Goal Gets Closer? explores how remaining timeframe, flexibility and the consequences of a market fall can change as the intended use of the money approaches.
Review the Goals Separately, Then Look at the Whole Plan
A useful review starts with each financial goal rather than with the total amount held across savings and investments. Once each goal has been considered separately, you can look at whether they still work together within your overall finances.
Review Saving and Investing Across Your Goals
Work through each goal separately before deciding whether the overall balance between saving and investing still makes sense.
-
Identify the goal
Define what the money is for, how much might be required and how much has already been accumulated.
-
Set the timeframe
Establish when the money may be needed and distinguish the preferred date from any genuinely fixed deadline.
-
Assess the consequences
Consider what would happen if the amount available were lower than expected when the goal arrived and how much flexibility you would have.
-
Allocate contributions
Consider how much of the money currently available can realistically be directed towards the goal alongside your other financial priorities.
-
Review as things change
Revisit the goal when its timeframe, target, contribution capacity or importance changes rather than assuming the original saving and investing balance must remain permanent.
There is no single saving-and-investing percentage that needs to apply to all of your money. The balance can emerge from the different jobs, timeframes and levels of flexibility attached to your individual financial goals.
After considering the goals separately, look at the combined demands they place on your finances. Contributions that appeared affordable for one goal may be unrealistic when several goals are considered together.
This can also reveal when priorities have changed. A goal may have become more urgent, another may have moved further away, or something you were previously working towards may no longer matter. Income and expenditure can change as well.
The purpose of reviewing the whole plan is therefore not to maintain a predetermined split between savings and investments. It is to make sure that the way money is being allocated still reflects what each part of it is expected to achieve.
Conclusion
Balancing saving and investing for different goals is not about finding one percentage that applies to all of your money. Different goals can have different target amounts, timeframes, deadlines and consequences if the money available is lower than expected.
Saving may provide greater certainty for money where the amount and timing matter, while investing introduces uncertainty alongside the possibility of longer-term growth. One financial plan can therefore contain both, and in some circumstances even one goal can involve money with different roles and timeframes.
Start with the goals rather than the saving-and-investing split. By understanding what each amount is for, when it may be needed and how much flexibility exists, you can assess the role saving and investing play across the plan and review that balance as the goals themselves change.
